Pipeline Press
  • HOME
  • Books
    • Organs and Organists
    • Organ-isms Anecdotes Book
    • Organist at your service
    • Puzzle Book >
      • Grids
      • Puzzle Images
      • Errata
      • Solutions >
        • Alphabet soup
        • A-mazing tuner
        • Crosswords
        • Letter Ladders
        • Plain Difficult
        • Ring the Changes
        • Logic Problems
        • Spot the difference
        • Sudoku
        • Tricky Passages
        • Word Search
    • Looking Up
    • The Organ's Prayer
    • Olivier Latry in conversation
    • Paradisus Musicus
  • Recordings
    • Resounding Aftershocks CD
    • Organ Capers
  • Organists In the kitchen
    • RECIPE INDEX >
      • Gillian Weir
      • Dianne Halliday
      • Martin Doering-in English
      • Martin Doering-in German
      • Robin Peirce
      • Hannah Parry
      • Birger Petersen
      • Marie-Louise Langlais
      • Thierry Mechler
      • Nina De Sole
      • Martin Setchell
      • Roberto Bertero
      • Carson Cooman
      • Ronald Watson
      • Katherine Dienes-Williams
      • Grimoaldo Macchia
      • Alexander Kellarev
      • Dorothy Young Riess
      • Andreas Willscher
      • Katelyn Emerson
      • Agnes Armstrong
      • Michael Barone
      • Claudius Winterhalter
      • Titus Grenyer
      • Alison Clark
      • Paul Spicer
      • Christiane Sauter-Pflomm
      • James Kibbie
      • James Flores
      • Inoue Hiroko​
      • Barry Jordan
      • Gareth Perkins
      • Thomas Ospital
    • Notes on weights and measures
  • Newsletters
  • Gifts
  • Articles & Reviews
    • Book & CD reviews >
      • Bevington
      • Booths of Wakefield
      • The Organ of Saint Sulpice, Paris
      • Messaien - Pierre Pincemaille
      • The Music of Ripon Cathedral
      • The Nordic - Baltic Organ Book
      • A Life in Music
      • Franck played by Pincemaille
      • Mystical vision
      • Noëls of Louis-Claude Daquin
      • Homage à Daniel Roth
      • Bach's complete works
      • Organ works of JPE Hartmann
      • The Box of Whistles ​by John Norman
      • Kristiaan Seynhave plays César Franck
      • Bach Orgelwerke played by Michael Radulescu
      • Le Grand Cavaillé-Coll de la Cathédrale d’Angers
      • The Organs and Organists of Ludlow Parish Church
      • The Hakims at Sacré Coeur
    • 2002 >
      • Alfred Hollins
      • Snetzler-1
      • Snetzler-2
      • Organ Voices
      • Organ Blowers 1
      • Organ Blowers 2
      • Organ Blowers 3
      • Organ Cases
      • Organ Cases 2
      • Organ Cases 3
    • 2003 >
      • Organ Cases 4
      • Architects and organ builders
      • Plain vanilla or chocolate?
      • Canterbury Cousins
      • Blenheim Palace and elsewhere
      • Ornament - applied and misapplied
      • Of hats and arms
      • Invisible organs
      • Organ Anthology
      • Organ Anthology Part 2
      • Ghosts
    • 2004 >
      • Spanish Fly
      • The Wonderful Woofyt
      • Mine's bigger than yours
      • Flames, frets and fiddles
      • Angelicals
      • Telegram from America
      • Booth's Puffs
      • Barker Lever
      • Bettering Barker
      • Alternative Hymn Book
      • Tale of Two Organs
      • Tale of Two Organs (continued)
      • Guitarists do it better
      • Music for the feast of Christmas
    • 2005 >
      • The art of improvisation
      • Records and Reminiscences
      • The Case is Altered
      • Fashion Notes
      • Two town Halls - Sydney & Reading
      • The organ that time and men forgot
      • Edward Heath
      • Tin Whistles
      • Secrets of the Opera
      • Singing in the train
      • Buttoning up
    • 2006 >
      • Automobile blues
      • Pipes and packing cases
      • Harry remembers
      • Harry remembers 2
      • Bismarck and the pipe organ
      • Harry remembers 3
      • Playing Aids 1
      • Playing Aids 2
      • Connections
    • 2007 >
      • The birthday Present
      • Harry Remembers 4
      • Playing Aids 3
      • Wonder of Gascony
      • Gilding the Lily
      • A Most Eloquent Music
      • Seeing Double - Part 1
      • Seeing Double - Part 2
      • Humble Relations - American branch
      • Humble Relations - French branch
      • Tops, Noils, Shoddy and Mungo
      • Tops, Noils, and Handel's Messiah
    • 2008 >
      • Neanderthal Hymn Writer
      • Brindley and Foster Byway
      • The demise of Brindley and Foster
      • Flying High
      • Dorothea, Queen of Denmark - and an organ​
      • Time's Ever-Rolling Stream
    • 2009 >
      • Giving them names
      • Dudley Savage
      • Three organ cases
      • Henery's finest hour
      • Sneezes from the Organ Loft
      • 20th Century Organists
      • Philip Marshall Part 2
      • Part 2 20th Century organists
      • More sneezes from the organ loft
      • Country church curiosity
    • 2010 >
      • The Italian Face of Salzburg
      • Ladies at the Console
      • Gothic organ cases
      • Gothick organ cases
      • Orders and decorations
      • Organs-in-fiction
      • Christmas-recipes
    • 2011 >
      • Oddments and Oddities
      • Memorials and Monuments
      • A Cunning Player - King David
      • Facing the Music
      • Celestial Bands
      • Look-Up
      • Durham-Degrees
    • 2013 >
      • Archibald McIndoe
      • Brigadier-Wagthorpe
    • 2017 >
      • Transports of Delight
  • JIGSAW PUZZLES
  • Competitions
  • Sheet music
  • Photos
  • Calendars
  • Links
  • Blog
  • About Us - and other info
    • Contact Us
    • Search
    • NZOrgan
    • Part 1 of Jenny's earthquake story
    • Part 2 of Jenny's earthquake story
    • Shipping >
      • Returns & refunds
      • Privacy policy
Previous
Index
Next

David Bridgeman-Sutton wonders what might have been, in a . . . 
Picture

Tale of Two Organs
* Note that this was written before the 2010-2011 earthquakes that closed Christchurch Cathedral

 Did Neville Barnett intend William Hill to build the new organ for Christchurch Cathedral?

​The specification he drew up in 1880 was typical of that firm’s work with details of, perhaps, a decade earlier. The instrument actually installed two years later (job no: 1772 in Hill’s Shop Book) differs only slightly from Barnett’s proposal, with more modish stops (Salicional and Harmonic Flute) substituted for the obsolescent Keraulophon and unfashionable Wald Flute.

Slum life
Pic 1. Christchurch Cathedral, New Zealand
Christchurch Cathedral website
The cost of St David's organ appears to have been only £1450, which was £150 less than the original estimate. It is possible that, if Willis had won the Christchurch contract, he would have supplied an organ with a more comprehensive stop-list than that of his Welsh organ. Barnett specified a Great Open Diapason of “No 1 scale”; the Shop Book shows that the firm’s “Full scale” of c. 6 ¼” (160mm) diameter at CC was employed.

Just as typical of its builder was the markedly different Willis organ made, at the same time, for St David’s Cathedral in Wales.

In the course of extensive consultation, influential voices recommended the Christchurch authorities to engage Willis to undertake their work. These included that of Sir F.A.G. Ouseley, Professor of Music at Oxford. Estimates were obtained from both firms. Hill’s at £1400 was £544 below Willis’s, a substantial difference that decided the matter in the former’s favour.
Picture
Pic. 2: St David's, Wales (Click image to enlarge)
St David's website
The two specifications may be compared in the table below.​
Christchurch: Hill 1882
St David's: Willis 1883
Picture
​The different structure of the diapason choruses is worth study. The Willis standard mixture, then and for years thereafter, was the 3 rank sesquialtera, 17-19-22. His tierce rank was always voiced more softly than the quint and unison, so that the mixture is less anti-social than many of this composition. The omission of a swell mixture is surprising but not remarkable; many Willis organs, some larger than this, lacked the stop at this time. It is difficult to determine the rationale on which the decision to omit or include was made.

People at both Christchurch and St David's seemed well-pleased with their organs, especially, perhaps, Neville Barnett who got almost exactly what he wanted. One thing is certain: if Willis had secured the contract, Barnett and everyone else would have got what Willis thought they ought to have wanted.

David Bridgeman-Sutton,
September 5, 2004

Credits:
The early history of Christchurch Cathedral organ – and of many others in the Province is treated fully in Dr Ronald Newton’s Organa Cantuariensia which has been consulted extensively.
Pic 1. is reproduced from Dr Newton’s book with his permission and that of the Dean and Chapter of Christchurch.
Pic 2. from The Organs of St David's by Geraint Bowen is reproduced by permission of the Dean and Chapter of that cathedral.
Picture

looking for SOMETHING?

Books
Recordings
Printed music
​
Photographs
Gifts
​Calendars
​Blog
​
Links

Puzzle book grids and solutions
(Free registration & log in required)
GENERAL INFO
Contact
About Us
​
Search
​


Our earthquake stories

Support

Shipping
Returns and refunds
Privacy and Cookie declaration

© COPYRIGHT 2025 ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.